December 16, 2009

1st-century shroud find

A team of archaeologists and scientists says it has, for the first time, found pieces of a burial shroud from the time of Jesus in a tomb in Jerusalem.

The researchers, from Hebrew University and institutions in Canada and the US, said the shroud was very different from the controversial Turin Shroud. . .

The newly found cloth has a simpler weave than Turin's, the scientists say.

The body of a man wrapped in fragments of the shroud was found in a tomb dating from the time of Jesus near the Old City of Jerusalem.

From the BBC.

Posted by David on December 16, 2009 1:12 PM

Comments

So a Jewish priest or aristocrat with Leprosy would have necessarily been wrapped in the same product from the local "Shrouds R' Us" shop as an itinerant carpenter/preacher/Messiah? Where's the logic in that? These idiot pressniks can't get their articles published unless they at least purport to disprove some article of Christian belief. Bah, Humbug.

Posted by: doug in Colorado on December 16, 2009 6:08 PM

It is difficult to evaluate the BBC report, abbreviated and generalized as it is. Although I am a skeptic of the claims for the Turin Shroud, there are, however, logical fallacies with the BBC report that may be of interest. First. there is no reaon to believe that only one particular weave of cloth was used in the region in the first century. Second, the supposed recent dating of the Turin Shroud has been sown to be based on contaminated samples and the actual dates are unknown. Third, spore and pollen samples of the Turin Shroud have been held to have Middle Eastern, not European affinities. Fourth, issues have been raised bu the analysses done by the McCrone laboratory.

The Turin Shroud never seems to lack attention and is by the fact of its fame and claims. Of course as the late Carl Sagin stated, "extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence." But by the same logic, claims that the Shroud of Turin is not very special, does require sufficent evidence of that fact. The BBC report does not meet that standard of evidence, and the Turin Shroud remains a mystery.

Posted by: Donald Wolberg on December 18, 2009 12:22 AM
Post a comment




  Remember Me?


(For bold text to display correctly, please use <strong>, not <b>)




Google