June 3, 2008

"It never hurts to talk" -- or does it?

BARACK OBAMA FIRST VOWED to meet unconditionally with the leaders of America's foremost enemies in the YouTube Democratic candidates' debate on July 23, 2007. Since then he has reaffirmed and expanded on the commitment in a variety of contexts. . .

In Portland on May 18, Obama cited John F. Kennedy's 1961 summit with Soviet premier Nikita Khrushchev in Vienna among the series of negotiations that led to America's triumph over the Soviet Union in the Cold War. The Vienna summit, however, disproves Obama's assertion regarding the unvarying value of meetings between enemy heads of state about as decisively as any historical episode can refute a thesis.

Although the article is clearly partisan, its central argument need not be: the notion that there is no downside to parley is widespread across the political spectrum. Read the rest here.

Posted by David on June 3, 2008 9:36 AM

Comments

Talks, even among actual belligerents, are almost always undertaken. But first at third-hand (Spain in WWII carrying messages between Allies and Axis), low-level bureaucrats (e.g. suggesting trade negotiations), high-level bureaucrats (Consuls and Ambassadors bearing messages from the governments they represent) etc. to set, yes, pre-conditions prior to actual meetings. Heck, there were pre-conditions concerning Winston Churchills visiting with Franklin Roosevelt - the two "Naval Gentlemen" were not exactly representing antagonists.

So the question is what is meant by "without pre-conditions." If BHO meant not setting terms of possible problem resolution (while perhaps agreeing on an agenda of things to be discussed), fine. And if he'd say so, fine. But that is not waht is coming from him or his handlers/staff/supporters, even though I think it is what he meant, and that is worrying for an over-reaction to what should be a minor point.

Posted by: teqjack on June 3, 2008 6:53 PM
Post a comment




  Remember Me?


(For bold text to display correctly, please use <strong>, not <b>)




Google